I very much enjoyed the characters. They just seemed so genuine that I could picture them so clearly in my mind… In fact, I’m sure my brain at some points forgot that they are not real people
TW: Book contains many themes involving/speaking about death.
Intro
Hello there, and welcome to another of my book reviews! It has been almost a month since my last book review, mainly due to exams… But exams are now (hopefully!) out of the way for good! *Cheers internally* Which I am quite pleased about, as I have had a couple book reviews in my head ready to type out, but haven’t had the time to do so, and I can finally get it out of my head and over to you!
So, let’s get into it! But first, a quick trigger warning. Death is one of the central themes of the book, and this post will speak a bit about that, so please skip this post if it might be upsetting to you – you have my permission to stop reading!
About the book
The book switches between the perspective of Manelle and Ambroise. Let’s start with Manelle. She is a home help carer for the elderly in a small French town, so she gets to see quite a wide-range of people which, inevitably, includes some very bizarre personalities, but also some very friendly personalities with the ability to charm warmth into anyone’s heart. One of the latter kinds of people will change Manelle’s life forever when he makes a request she feels she cannot possibly accept.
Next is Ambroise, an embalmer (this is basically dealing with a dead body so it is presentable for the funeral, but might also include a theme to symbolise a person’s personality or life to give the person as good as send-off as possible). While he himself takes a lot of pride in what he does, unfortunately it is something which seems to put a lot of people off, or makes people act a little weird around him, so much so that he appears to have given up on a love life. It even seems to put his Father off of him, and the two no longer speak. Also featuring in the story in Ambrose’s Grandmother, with whom he lives.
Through a series of events, Ambroise ends up in contact with an elderly person who has made a request… The same request that Manelle could not possibly accept. And this is the point where the story of Manelle and the story of Ambrose (and his Grandmother) starts to come together, as we see these characters go on a journey, and it seems that nothing will be the same for any of them, ever again.
I… Thought it was ok
I must admit that, at times, I found this book very difficult to read, not because of the book itself, but because of the common theme of death (including scenes describing the embalming process). Like many people, the thought of it is something that terrifies me, and I sometimes felt myself getting a little nervous when reading certain scenes, especially the embalming scenes. Because of this, I made sure that I only read the book during the day… Never at night. I made that mistake once, and that was enough for me not to repeat the same mistake. However, I have tried to ignore this when reviewing the book, because it seems unfair to give it a worse review just because I couldn’t read it at night.
I should also say that this was not, at all, a bad book. In fact, there were some things about the book that I very much enjoyed. However, there were some things I wasn’t so keen about which were true throughout most of the book which meant that, while I didn’t dislike the book, it just wasn’t that interesting a lot of the time. But because there were some very good and some things I didn’t enjoy, I think it is best to go through both individually!
What I enjoyed
Firstly, I very much enjoyed the characters. They just seemed so genuine that I could picture them so clearly in my mind… In fact, I’m sure my brain at some points through the book forgot that they are not real people (as far as we know!). I think this is much more difficult than people think. It involves a deep understanding of your characters, and knowing how they would react if you were to put them into any situation. Sometimes, the actions of people seem random, impossible to predict, and sometimes completely irrational. So, for the writer to get a good grasp of how his/her characters might react in certain situations is actually very difficult – so I very much appreciate writers who are able to write characters in a way that their actions seem to make sense from what we know about them. And this is one of those examples.
The story also has some moments that will raise a range of emotions in the reader, and those moments usually lead to some great quotes – most of which are very deep, meaningful, but also quite clever and very well said… Well, very well worded, unless you listen to the audiobook, in which case it depends on whoever is reading the book to you, I guess…
What I didn’t enjoy
Thinking about it, there is only really one issue… But for me, it was a big one which caused a lot of smaller issues. That issue was the lack of conflict.
Pretty much every story will have one big dramatic question (in fact, I can’t think of any story that doesn’t have one) that the story will centre around, and one of the writer’s jobs is to make sure that the reader is constantly focussed on that very question, so that the answer to that dramatic question will be on the balance through the story, and may swing between two different answers to make things interesting. That usually means that there will be some sort of conflict, otherwise it would just be one answer winning out quite clearly.
But conflict seemed very rare in this story, despite there being many opportunities where conflict could have arisen – It seemed to me that there could have been many different tweaks in different places that could have made the story a lot more interesting. And there were moments where it seemed that there would be a conflict. In fact, one moment seemed perfect for conflict, which did arise… And then went very quickly and anti-climactically.
Because there was very little conflict, the story seemed very predictable. While a predictable ending is not necessarily a bad thing (i.e. the superhero almost always wins), the fact that much of the story itself was quite predictable meant it lost a lot of that excitement that usually makes you want to keep reading (it is this sort of story that makes you say “Just one more chapter” until it is 2am and you have finished the book).
It is a shame, because if a few things were different, and the story contained more conflict, I could very easily see myself changing my rating from ‘thought it was ok’ to ‘enjoyed’ or even ‘loved’. Because the story seemed to have it all… Other than the thing that adds interest and excitement in the novel. But who knows, perhaps this is something that I need to enjoy a novel, but that other people don’t necessarily need for a novel to be enjoyable – so if you think you might enjoy this novel, don’t let this post put you off!
Conclusion
Sorry for what was probably a little bit of a depressing book review… But let’s hope for a more positive book review next Monday. But for now, keep an eye out for my next ‘Bookish Post’ hopefully coming out on Wednesday. Until then, grab a hot drink and a book, for a lovely Monday evening!
TBT